← All Cases Coverage by Bryan K. Randolph · BrynoDC

Lac du Flambeau Band v. Coughlin

No. 22-227 SCOTUS · Decided Decided SCOTUS
Cert Granted: Jan 13, 2023 Argued: Apr 24, 2023 Decided: Jun 14, 2023

Case Overview

A tribe sought to use federal bankruptcy court to discharge a debt despite state claims of sovereign immunity, and the state argued its immunity barred the tribe from proceeding. The Supreme Court held 9-0 that the Bankruptcy Code abrogates state sovereign immunity as to tribal debtors exercising federal bankruptcy rights, applying the same analysis as established for state debtors.


The Facts

The Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians took out a payday loan and sought bankruptcy protection. The lender was a tribal entity. The tribe argued that its sovereign immunity barred proceedings in federal bankruptcy court. The question was whether the Bankruptcy Code's abrogation of tribal sovereign immunity was effective.

The Application

History

When the Lac du Flambeau Band sought bankruptcy protection, it invoked tribal sovereign immunity to prevent the lender from proceeding in federal bankruptcy court, arguing that its status as a federally recognized tribe gave it the same immunity shield available to states. The Court applied the Bankruptcy Code's abrogation language, holding that Congress had clearly intended the immunity waiver to encompass tribes as 'governmental units,' making the tribe's sovereign immunity claim unavailable as a defense. Because the Bankruptcy Code's text treated tribal governments the same way it treated state governments for purposes of the immunity abrogation, the tribe had to proceed through bankruptcy like any other debtor and could not use immunity to block the process.

The Conclusion

**Lac du Flambeau Band v. Coughlin resolved a circuit split by holding that the Bankruptcy Code's sovereign immunity waiver applies to tribes.** Tribes cannot invoke sovereign immunity to obstruct bankruptcy proceedings any more than states can, ensuring that the federal bankruptcy system functions uniformly for debtors regardless of the identity of creditors.

CourtSupreme Court of the United States
FiledSep 12, 2022
Judge -
CL Statusactive
View on CourtListener →

No circuit court data for this case.

Cert GrantedJan 13, 2023
Statusactive
Filed (CL)Sep 12, 2022
View on CourtListener →
SCOTUS TMR-98f541ec Jul 13, 2026
Subscribe on Substack ↗

This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support